Alabasta Is My Favorite Arc Because It's Supposed To Be So Middle Eastern! My Grandpa Is From Palestine

Alabasta is my favorite arc because it's supposed to be so middle eastern! My grandpa is from Palestine and raised my mom there. I'd seen rumors that a Palestinian actress was in consideration to be cast as Vivi and I'm just a little let down. I've seen dozens of pictures and videos of the Straw Hat jolly roger being used as a symbol of liberation at Free Palestine events. I just...thought this really could've been something for the movement. Idk.

I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman
I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman

I am very disappointed in OPLA's casting for Vivi and King Cobra ngl. I am a South Indian Muslim woman and Alabasta is literally one of my favorite arcs. Casting South Indian descent actors makes no sense because Alabasta is very clearly inspired by Middle Eastern and North African culture, particularly Egypt.

I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman

The clothing and archeticture makes the Egyptian influence in particular very obvious. Specifically Crocodile's rainbase, the Jackal and Falcon as the cities dieties, and the heiroglyphic treatment in the tomb where Luffy and Crocodile's final showdown happens really proves the influence is inargueably Egyptian. Vivi and Cobra's family name is even Nefetari which is so similar to Nefertiti, the most obvious ancient Egyptian name.

I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman
I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman
I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman
I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman
I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman
I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman

AND!!!

At the time Alabasta was being published in the manga, beginning around 2000...

I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman
I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman
I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman

...Palestine was going through the Second Intifada.

I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman
I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman

Other MENA countries also had protests and uprisings in solidarity. In autumn of 2000, the Egyptian ppl in fact rose up against their president, Hosni Mubarak, against his support of Israel and in solidarity with the Palestinian Second Intifada.

I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman
I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman

A lot of the story beats in Alabasta clearly took inspiration from the political movements in support of the Intifada. Considering that Palestine is going through a genocide and ethnic cleansing and one of the producers is very Pro Israel, I can't help but think the producers deliberately wanted to hide the arca's influences to MENA uprisings in support of Palestine. But it's in the DNA of Alabasta itself.

Additionally, there is this terrible TERRIBLE habit of Western production companies conflating India and MENA as the same. India has centuries of cross cultural exchange with the MENA region but our socities, archeticture, and clothing are VERY different. I come from a family that has been Muslim in India for generations and even still our clothes, archeticture, and cultural traditions are very distinctly different from MENA muslims. This is because majority of the Islamic influence into India did not even come from the MENA region, it came from the Mughal Empire which originated in Central Asia.

I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman

Below is Jama Masjid in New Delhi, India:

I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman

and here's the Grand Mosque in Cairo, Egypt:

I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman

Now compare Jama Masjid above with Meidan Emam in Esfahan, Iran

I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman

Of the three shown here, which one looks most like the palace in Alabasta?

I Am Very Disappointed In OPLA's Casting For Vivi And King Cobra Ngl. I Am A South Indian Muslim Woman

Its definitely not the masjid from India.

I'm very disappointed but unsurprised OPLA went in this direction. I would just like to encourage fans who aren't MENA or Indian to be more critical of these decisions as well. This casting is basically the same as the Disney Aladdin approach. Indians and MENA are not interchangeable.

I've been seeing a lot of posts celebrating that King Cobra and Vivi are not white and I would like to encourage those fans to reconsider giving Netflix and OPLA credit for representation when a critical look at the source material shows the casting decisions are incorrect and seem to be politically motivated. I know that Oda is deeply involved in OPLA but that still doesn't justify the swap.

More Posts from Vinsmokeemmy and Others

9 months ago

finally some good audio for what !! sounds like

9 months ago

Not to be the Usopp Defense Guy again, but whenever people complain about his more childlike or immature tendencies I'm like. Do you think the guy that was forced to grow up and raise himself when he was like seven or whatever, might have a reason to cling onto whimsy and childhood.

Do you think the the guy that was orphaned and forced to take care of himself and his survival and his house and his livelihood at an extremely young age, with barely any adults around, might have had a) trouble maturing properly and b) a desire to keep with him what was taken away by such an experience. Let him be whimsical. Let him laugh at immature jokes he's literally 17 pre-timeskip that's a kid. A kid that somehow self-taught himself the basics of engineering without a formal education, even. Don't let his playfulness distract you from how intelligent he is. Defending Usopp on the internet isn't enough I need a hammer. Potentially the inflatable fake type that can fool my enemies into thinking it's real.

9 months ago
So Smoker Gets Swapped With Tashigi And Turns Into The Baddest Bitch That Ever Walked?
So Smoker Gets Swapped With Tashigi And Turns Into The Baddest Bitch That Ever Walked?

so smoker gets swapped with tashigi and turns into the baddest bitch that ever walked?

9 months ago
I’m So In Love With Him It’s Not Funny
I’m So In Love With Him It’s Not Funny
I’m So In Love With Him It’s Not Funny
I’m So In Love With Him It’s Not Funny

i’m so in love with him it’s not funny

9 months ago

One piece episode 1112

Hey folks, I made some GIFs for you to use for whatever you wish. If you haven't watched the episode yet, maybe come back later.

One Piece Episode 1112
One Piece Episode 1112
One Piece Episode 1112
One Piece Episode 1112
One Piece Episode 1112
One Piece Episode 1112
One Piece Episode 1112
One Piece Episode 1112
One Piece Episode 1112
One Piece Episode 1112
9 months ago

Ok so let’s talk about a fairly well known OP Theory,

Is Kid a Vegapunk Satellite?

Ok So Let’s Talk About A Fairly Well Known OP Theory,
Ok So Let’s Talk About A Fairly Well Known OP Theory,

(I like to believe he is but I’m only 70% sure if this theory)

Now let’s talk (possible) history

So I believe Vegapunk made Kid to express all his anger so it wouldn’t blind HIS work. So after he made him, he left him somewhere far far away from Egghead (like in the South Blue)

Why would Vegapunk choose to leave his anger satellite on a scrap heap, no government protection island? Because the constant stress of possible danger and rude islanders is a perfect place for Anger to fester and stress to build. (An unnecessary evil from Vegapunk) but Anger can’t build and fester on a technical paradise.

Vegapunk probably never planned that Kid would ever even leave his island, nonetheless the South Blue itself to enter the Grand Line. When he first read about Kid’s atrocities, he was probably having a visceral reaction (not to the violence, Kid’s the anger part of the brain) but to the fact that he was making headway into the Grandline and became a Supernova.

What Vegapunk didn’t know while Anger can blind you, spite is also a pretty big motivator for angry people. He didn’t understand the idea that his satellite he made to seethe on an island somewhere would have goals and aspirations (like claiming the One Piece).

Now let’s move onto my other point, the number 7 on the Damned Punk

Ok So Let’s Talk About A Fairly Well Known OP Theory,

(Not to mention this is an actual Railgun, as in a FUTURE GUN)

Now why, why would Kid put a 07 there? There was no reason to add a 07 and yet he did, as if it was a type of instinct to put it on a creation he was proud of. Kinda like the Satellites

Ok So Let’s Talk About A Fairly Well Known OP Theory,

(Who also share the same Number system as Kid, 0 than a number.)

And while we’re on the topic of the other satellites, let’s draw some comparisons between Shaka and Killer’s mask.

Ok So Let’s Talk About A Fairly Well Known OP Theory,

It’s (somewhat) safe to assume Kid might’ve designed Killer’s mask as it seems to fit almost perfectly on him and shows none of his face (the exact specifications that Killer would probably want). It’s smooth and rounded kinda like Shaka’s and that beard sticking out almost resembles Shaka’s lower mask.

Now this point doesn’t have much meaning but it is interesting how similar they are.

Now you may ask “what about child kid, we’ve seen him and he was already on the island?” Well whose to say Vegapunk didn’t drop him off on that island even younger?

Ok So Let’s Talk About A Fairly Well Known OP Theory,

(Look he’s even holding a wrench and a toy robot he probably built himself.)

Childhood is also a person’s most impressionable time, so placing him in a negative environment at a young age was crucial to making him a bitter and angry so the others don’t feel that. (Seriously it’s unnecessarily cruel)

Now let’s talk about another point, Kid’s Face

Ok So Let’s Talk About A Fairly Well Known OP Theory,
Ok So Let’s Talk About A Fairly Well Known OP Theory,

Look at his face it’s got a sort of Perma-Malice to it, wouldn’t you agree? Like his face was made to feel every bad emotion of a person. Now let’s take a look at his smile, clearly scary and kinda unnerving, as if he’s not supposed to smile. Now let’s compare that smile to the grimace on the right, it looks almost perfect, as if that’s how his face should look. I’m fact, I don’t think I’ve ever seen Kid smile while he wasn’t being malicious in some way.

It’s like the only reason he smiles is to piss off his enemies and look smug, meanwhile that grimace is a fairly common face that we’ve seen many a time whether pissed off or sad. It’d make sense for the Satellite of Anger to have a face more inclined to make a resting bitch face.

Anyways I think if Kid had made it to Egghead, the Satellites would be very tense around him. Kinda like how you’d tense up if you don’t want someone to figure out a secret but they’re on the tip of figuring it out. Like “please, please just leave. Don’t make eye contact with us”.

Also Kid looks vaguely like Lilith, what with the both of them having kinda defined chins. Kid’s chin is more square than Lilith’s but that smile is almost a dead ringer

Ok So Let’s Talk About A Fairly Well Known OP Theory,

(And you got to admit they look vaguely like siblings for some reason.)

Last point I have here is his devil fruit, we know Kid got it at a fairly young age and that’s why he’s so adept at using it but we also can assume that Kid did a bunch of experimentation with it. Seeing what he could and couldn’t do and all his limitations, just like a scientist would.

It got to the point where Kid was 100% confident in the idea that he could make his Punk Rotten

Ok So Let’s Talk About A Fairly Well Known OP Theory,

A giant robot made of magnetized metal (kinda like the fake sea kings of the Vegapunks). Kid was so confident in his abilities to make this thing because he’s tested himself multiple times and trained himself to the peak of his devil fruit.

(Idk I like this theory and I think I’d be cool with it if it were true.)

While I do like some of the points you make, I can't say I really like this theory at all to be honest. It seems too coincidental and there's a fair amount of holes in it, the biggest of which being that the satellites were only conceptualized and created during the timeskip. Plus why would a perfectionist like Vegapunk pull a Star Wars and release a number 7 satellite decades before 1-6 were made? If we're talking about Kid representing spite, Atlas already covers that because a lot of her job is griping about her frustrations about not having enough resources to patent inventions and then take out those frustrations through violence. As for Kid not smiling in a way that doesn't look malicious, there's plenty of other characters who do that too, Doflamingo and Blackbeard being some of the most prominent.

Ok So Let’s Talk About A Fairly Well Known OP Theory,
Ok So Let’s Talk About A Fairly Well Known OP Theory,

You can also count Kaido in that, barring his goofy drunk expressions.

Ok So Let’s Talk About A Fairly Well Known OP Theory,

But the real reason why I'm not a fan of Kid being a Vegapunk is that a big part of his appeal lies in how he doesn't have some secret past. He's not related to anyone famous, he didn't have a mythical Devil Fruit or a warlord being an influential figure in his childhood. He was just a scrappy kid with a knack for robotics on some scrap island in the middle of nowhere who fought hard and viciously for everything he had and got to the top by his own merits. Vegapunk is far from the only genius in the One Piece world, Franky was an engineering prodigy long before he ever looked at Vegapunk's blueprints in Baltigo.

In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if the South Blue had a reputation for being home to a lot of technicians and shipwrights.

8 months ago
I'm Feral For Them Rn

I'm feral for them rn

9 months ago
Average Day On Social Media...

Average day on social media...

8 months ago
vinsmokeemmy - crocomom truther

vinsmokeemmy - crocomom truther

Slayleigh

And

Slayger

9 months ago
archiveofourown.org
An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works

You want my treasure? You can have it! I left everything I gathered together in one place. Now you just have to find it.

:)

trying my hand at writing. idk, just a zosan one shot. i just love these cartoon pirates man, and i wanna make them pathetically in love with one another.


Tags
Loading...
End of content
No more pages to load
  • mika-lin
    mika-lin liked this · 1 month ago
  • ravenspiritlin
    ravenspiritlin reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • ravenspiritlin
    ravenspiritlin liked this · 1 month ago
  • therealmoogler
    therealmoogler liked this · 2 months ago
  • mycatatemyburger
    mycatatemyburger liked this · 6 months ago
  • fat-rhinos
    fat-rhinos reblogged this · 6 months ago
  • fat-rhinos
    fat-rhinos liked this · 6 months ago
  • 1982brucespringsteen
    1982brucespringsteen liked this · 6 months ago
  • randomstuff-org
    randomstuff-org liked this · 6 months ago
  • haru-ayumu
    haru-ayumu reblogged this · 6 months ago
  • haru-ayumu
    haru-ayumu liked this · 6 months ago
  • seaotter-pop
    seaotter-pop liked this · 6 months ago
  • orchidnecromancer
    orchidnecromancer liked this · 6 months ago
  • gentlygolden
    gentlygolden reblogged this · 7 months ago
  • placespeople1776
    placespeople1776 liked this · 7 months ago
  • blackholesun321
    blackholesun321 liked this · 7 months ago
  • alex-blanc141
    alex-blanc141 liked this · 7 months ago
  • miamista13
    miamista13 liked this · 7 months ago
  • big-dumb-himbo
    big-dumb-himbo liked this · 7 months ago
  • rose-petalls
    rose-petalls liked this · 8 months ago
  • peoplealreadydieeveryday
    peoplealreadydieeveryday liked this · 8 months ago
  • sunspotstuff
    sunspotstuff liked this · 8 months ago
  • neon-nuggets
    neon-nuggets liked this · 8 months ago
  • -psycho-
    -psycho- liked this · 8 months ago
  • bestkeptbasement
    bestkeptbasement liked this · 8 months ago
  • theoisinthevoid
    theoisinthevoid reblogged this · 8 months ago
  • theoisinthevoid
    theoisinthevoid liked this · 8 months ago
  • krownest
    krownest liked this · 8 months ago
  • narwhalpanda
    narwhalpanda reblogged this · 8 months ago
  • 22ouncebitch
    22ouncebitch reblogged this · 8 months ago
  • lilserotoninpls
    lilserotoninpls liked this · 8 months ago
  • sweet-ch3rry
    sweet-ch3rry liked this · 8 months ago
  • luli3
    luli3 liked this · 8 months ago
  • toonar0ll
    toonar0ll liked this · 8 months ago
  • finch-velutina
    finch-velutina liked this · 8 months ago
  • superapricotpersongarden
    superapricotpersongarden liked this · 8 months ago
  • werewolfin
    werewolfin reblogged this · 8 months ago
  • werewolfin
    werewolfin liked this · 8 months ago
  • the-amazing-digital-guardians-au
    the-amazing-digital-guardians-au liked this · 8 months ago
  • nbblacksheep
    nbblacksheep liked this · 8 months ago
  • mylittleminxxx
    mylittleminxxx liked this · 8 months ago
  • hiraethdays
    hiraethdays liked this · 8 months ago
  • tamaotamamura
    tamaotamamura liked this · 8 months ago
  • marxistluffyist
    marxistluffyist liked this · 8 months ago
  • honeybaybee29
    honeybaybee29 liked this · 8 months ago
  • thornew
    thornew liked this · 8 months ago
  • uemangero
    uemangero liked this · 8 months ago
  • alovelyocean
    alovelyocean reblogged this · 8 months ago
  • dreamereternal
    dreamereternal liked this · 9 months ago
vinsmokeemmy - crocomom truther
crocomom truther

i'm Em! 25 she/heri love one piece

100 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags